The N.Y. Senate manoeuvrings are starting to put pressure on the governor, and this caretaker option now being floated could be a viable way out of the maelstrom developing. The last thing that is needed in Democratic politics in the U.S. right now is another chaotic Senate appointment. I still believe Caroline Kennedy would be a good bet to win the seat in a few years if she were required to wait while this caretaker minds the store in any event. Like it or not, it's reality that she's got the stuff that counts in the U.S. these days, money raising ability, name and significant supporters like Mayor Bloomberg. And put me down as one who believes that the minimization of her qualifications is not justified. Chances are good that she'd exceed present expectations and defeat other Democratic challengers for all the, you know, aforementioned factors. But there are enough candidates who are equally credible and present solid credentials for that seat, including N.Y. Attorney General Andrew Cuomo and U.S. House Representative Carolyn Maloney, among others. With all of these candidates now informally running and putting up their flags, the governor may not have a choice but to put in a place holder and let them fight it out in a Democratic primary. That seems like the more responsible course at this point.
There is legality and then there is the ever important concept of legitimacy that must be factored in as well. Blagojevich did what is technically legal but has highly questionable legitimacy. His pick is now suffering the fallout. Paterson, by picking the place holder route, can ensure legality and legitimacy. When the two go hand in hand, that's a good indicator of the route to follow.
Speaking of one of the rumoured place holders, did you see this last night? They looked pretty good and darn happy. I wouldn't mind seeing Bubba in the Senate!
More reading on this: a plea for the governor to act decisively and soon, the right wing suddenly has a reason to support Kennedy, another in favour of the place holder.
Update (9:00 p.m.): Governor Paterson said no to the caretaker option today. Resume speculating.
Update (Fri. Jan. 2, 7:10 p.m.): Kennedy is looking to be Paterson's choice, the word is leaking out.